Life Insurance Australia :: News

Share this news item!

Insurer's Denial Upheld for 'Reckless and Unsafe' Driver

Insurer's Denial Upheld for 'Reckless and Unsafe' Driver

A recent appeal by a driver involved in a single-vehicle accident has been unsuccessful in overturning his insurer's claim denial.
The insurer cited exclusions related to the driver's reckless driving and an unroadworthy vehicle as the basis for their decision.

The driver, who was operating a 2020 BMW X4, stated that the accident occurred at approximately 8pm on May 22nd of last year while he was attempting to navigate a bend in the road. According to the driver, he lost control of the vehicle and collided with a tree due to being startled by the bright lights of an oncoming vehicle.

Initially, Blue Zebra, the insurer, notified the insured that his claim had been approved and would be assessed as a total loss. Approval was granted for the purchase of a new vehicle for the claimant pending an interview with the driver about the accident, as well as approval from the vehicle's financier. The purchase was based on a $197,214 quote provided by the complainant.

However, despite still awaiting further claim information, Blue Zebra proceeded to place an order for a new vehicle, as it was estimated that the replacement would take about ten months to arrive. However, on August 8th, the insured informed the insurer that he had placed an order, which included a $2000 deposit, with another dealership and expected to receive the vehicle by the end of the month.

Safety Issues and Reckless Driving

An insurer-appointed motor vehicle investigator, referred to as AM, reported significant safety concerns regarding the insured vehicle at the time of the crash. These concerns included unroadworthy tires and disabled stability controls.

The investigator also noted crash data indicating that the driver was traveling 12km/h above the speed limit and took deliberate actions to increase speed moments before the accident. According to AM, the vehicle was being driven in an enthusiastic and reckless manner, exceeding the speed limit and with disabled stability controls.

Claim Denial and Disputes

Following an interview with the complainant regarding the accident, Blue Zebra denied the claim, stating that exclusions related to the vehicle's unsafe and unroadworthy condition, as well as the insured's wilful and reckless use of the car, were applicable.

The insured, however, maintains that the car was in pristine condition before the accident, having received appropriate servicing and driven only 19,000km in total. He denies any knowledge of issues with the tires and asserts that he would have addressed them if he had been aware.

Moreover, the driver disputes the accusation of driving recklessly, emphasizing that he would not have endangered himself or his son, who was a passenger at the time of the accident.

Ruling of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (A.F.C.A.) reviewed the evidence presented by both parties and concluded that the insurer was justified in denying the claim. A.F.C.A. accepted AM's report, which unequivocally established the unroadworthy condition of the vehicle, thereby contradicting the insured's assertions.

The ruling also took into account the insured's admission of driving above the legal speed limit, despite being unfamiliar with the road. Therefore, A.F.C.A. agreed that the insured was likely driving in a wilful and reckless manner immediately prior to the accident.

A.F.C.A. did, however, determine that Blue Zebra should compensate the insured for the financial losses caused by the initial indications of claim acceptance. This includes reimbursing the $2000 deposit that the policyholder had paid.

Published:Tuesday, 21st Nov 2023

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Homeowner Successfully Challenges Insurer in Disclosure Dispute Homeowner Successfully Challenges Insurer in Disclosure Dispute
09 Dec 2023:

A property owner, whose home was recently flooded, has won a legal battle against his insurer over the denial of his claim. The insurer, Auto & General Services, had alleged that the homeowner breached his policy terms by not disclosing a business operation in a farm shed on the property. - read more
Senate Inquiry to Shine Spotlight on Insurance Outcomes in Retirement System Senate Inquiry to Shine Spotlight on Insurance Outcomes in Retirement System
08 Dec 2023:

The Australian retirement system is under examination as a new Senate inquiry focuses on improving consumer experiences, choice, and outcomes. The Economics References Committee has been tasked with investigating various aspects, including general and life insurance, and is expected to deliver its findings by June 30, 2024. - read more
Insurers Embrace New Model Allowing 'Simple Advice' Insurers Embrace New Model Allowing 'Simple Advice'
08 Dec 2023:

General insurers have been given the green light to offer 'simple advice' under a new model presented by Financial Services Minister Stephen Jones. The Albanese Government's response to the Quality of Advice Review (QAR) final report includes this move, which has received strong backing from the insurance industry. - read more
Insurer Prevails in Dispute Over Misrepresentation of Mental Health Insurer Prevails in Dispute Over Misrepresentation of Mental Health
05 Dec 2023:

An individual who failed to disclose her history of mental health and medication use in her life insurance application has lost her dispute with the insurer. - read more
Flood Damage: A Disproportionate Risk to Known Exposure Flood Damage: A Disproportionate Risk to Known Exposure
05 Dec 2023:

Flood events have accounted for a staggering 54% of losses from declared insurance events in the past five years. Surprisingly, these losses occur even though only a small percentage of properties are known to be at risk, according to a submission by the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) to a parliamentary inquiry. - read more

Life Insurance Articles

How Much Life Insurance Do I Need? How Much Life Insurance Do I Need?
There are many different reasons to purchase life insurance (generation skipping tax, estate plan, estate preservation, surviving spouse needs, planning for your children's future and more). There is no right amount of life insurance, but here are some guidelines that might help you decide how much life insurance you need. - read more
Life Insurance for Millennials: Why It's Essential. Life Insurance for Millennials: Why It's Essential.
As a millennial, you may believe that you're young, healthy, and have plenty of time to prepare for the future. However, it's essential to understand that life is unpredictable, and unexpected events can occur at any time. This is why it's essential to consider life insurance, particularly if you have financial responsibilities, dependents, or both. - read more
Who Needs Disability Insurance? Who Needs Disability Insurance?
If you are like most people on this planet, you are not financially free. You would not be able to stop working and still support yourself and your family from your financial resources. Your continued ability to work to earn an income would therefore be one of your greatest assets. - read more
Loss of income insurance: Case Study Loss of income insurance: Case Study
Rebecca is a single, self-employed graphic designer who works from home. Aged in her mid-30s, she has monthly commitments of a mortgage and car payments and the usual living expenses. - read more
The importance of Income Protection Insurance for Employees The importance of Income Protection Insurance for Employees
While some people might think that income protection insurance is only for self-employed individuals, this is not accurate. This type of insurance is just as beneficial for employees, because accidents and illnesses can happen to anyone at any time. Workers' compensation provides only limited coverage, and most employees don't have much more than a few weeks' sick leave accrued. Of course, if you have more than one job, the situation becomes more of a concern if you are injured at one workplace resulting in being unable to work at either. - read more

Start Here !
life insurance
Apply now for your free Insurance assessment and price comparisons!

Life Cover Amount:
Your Postcode:
All quotes are provided free and without obligation. We respect your privacy.

Professional indemnity:
An insurance that provides cover for liability incurred in the course of exercising a profession.