The claim was initiated after the man's wife had a severe fall down a flight of stairs during their trip to Thailand. She sustained multiple injuries, including a fractured hip and head trauma, which required her to be hospitalized for more than three weeks. Additionally, to ensure a safe journey back to Melbourne, the claimant had to purchase a business class flight for his wife, allowing her to lie flat and minimize the risk of complications.
Zurich Australia denied the claim based on the policy's exclusion of overseas medical expenses for individuals over 80 years old. However, Zurich claimed to have offered an "upgrade" to the policy, providing medical coverage for individuals over 80, which the claimant did not opt for.
The complainant obtained the policy through a local branch of his bank, referred to as CB, which offered it as a benefit for specific credit card holders. At the time of purchasing the policy, both the complainant and his wife were 81 and 80 years old, respectively.
Making an effort to follow the correct procedure given his limited computer skills, Mr. E visited the local CB branch on June 30. He expected the staff to guide him through the application process for the policy.
Mr. E alleged that the CB staff failed to inform him about the need to "upgrade" the policy in order to ensure adequate coverage for medical expenses. He left the bank under the impression that he and his wife were appropriately insured, even receiving an email confirmation from the insurer stating that the policy had been activated.
AFCA considered the claimant's assertion that a bank teller, referred to as SH, had assisted him during the application process. Despite Zurich's objections, the ruling ombudsman agreed with Mr. E's account.
The ruling acknowledged that SH had neglected to disclose the requirement to "upgrade" the policy, necessary for the claimant and his wife to have coverage, despite the bank being aware of their age. It stated that although SH's actions were unintentional, CB caused the insured party to believe they had suitable coverage.
"Given CB's knowledge of the complainants' age, this omission should have been disclosed," AFCA stated.
"SH's oversight significantly contributed to Mr. E's unwitting failure to apply for the policy upgrade. Furthermore, this omission induced Mr. E to enter into an insurance contract that he believed provided adequate coverage. However, unbeknownst to him, the policy was essentially useless in terms of overseas medical expense coverage for both him and Mrs. E."
Zurich argued that CB employees were not authorized representatives and thus were unable to offer any advice on the credit card insurance being offered. However, AFCA dismissed this argument as an attempt by the insurer to absolve itself of CB's shortcomings, stating that the bank acted, at least partially, in the insurer's interest.
The decision mandates that Zurich accept the claim and provides a compensation of $4000 ($2000 for each complainant) for non-financial losses resulting from the insurer's claim denial and subsequent challenges.
"Throughout the claims process, the insurer's stance has unfortunately caused the complainants, particularly Mr. E, to feel accused of dishonesty," expressed AFCA.
"They also feel that their recollections have been questioned. Moreover, the insurer's position in this claim has been based on flimsy evidence."
Published:Friday, 17th Nov 2023
Source: financialservicesonline.com.au
![]() | Homeowner Successfully Challenges Insurer in Disclosure Dispute 09 Dec 2023: .financialservicesonline.com.au A property owner, whose home was recently flooded, has won a legal battle against his insurer over the denial of his claim. The insurer, Auto & General Services, had alleged that the homeowner breached his policy terms by not disclosing a business operation in a farm shed on the property. - read more |
![]() | Senate Inquiry to Shine Spotlight on Insurance Outcomes in Retirement System 08 Dec 2023: .financialservicesonline.com.au The Australian retirement system is under examination as a new Senate inquiry focuses on improving consumer experiences, choice, and outcomes. The Economics References Committee has been tasked with investigating various aspects, including general and life insurance, and is expected to deliver its findings by June 30, 2024. - read more |
![]() | Insurers Embrace New Model Allowing 'Simple Advice' 08 Dec 2023: .financialservicesonline.com.au General insurers have been given the green light to offer 'simple advice' under a new model presented by Financial Services Minister Stephen Jones. The Albanese Government's response to the Quality of Advice Review (QAR) final report includes this move, which has received strong backing from the insurance industry. - read more |
![]() | Insurer Prevails in Dispute Over Misrepresentation of Mental Health 05 Dec 2023: .financialservicesonline.com.au An individual who failed to disclose her history of mental health and medication use in her life insurance application has lost her dispute with the insurer. - read more |
![]() | Flood Damage: A Disproportionate Risk to Known Exposure 05 Dec 2023: .financialservicesonline.com.au Flood events have accounted for a staggering 54% of losses from declared insurance events in the past five years. Surprisingly, these losses occur even though only a small percentage of properties are known to be at risk, according to a submission by the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) to a parliamentary inquiry. - read more |
![]() | Loss of income insurance: Case Study Rebecca is a single, self-employed graphic designer who works from home. Aged in her mid-30s, she has monthly commitments of a mortgage and car payments and the usual living expenses. - read more
|
![]() | Income protection insurance It's trite but true to say that, for most people, their most valuable asset is their ability to earn an income. But how relevant is income insurance to most Australians? - read more
|
![]() | Why life insurance is a necessity in tough times With household budgets under pressure ... and consumer confidence weak, many families are wondering whether life insurance is worth the expense. Or maybe it is something they can do without? - read more
|
![]() | DIY Review Checklist for your Income Protection Insurance If you have an income protection insurance plan already - or are thinking about buying one, then you need to be aware that these policies require regular maintenance and careful scrutiny to ensure that they adequately meet your needs. Unfortunately, many people purchase income protection insurance policies only to find out about their shortcomings at claim time. - read more
|
![]() | Life Insurance: How much is enough? When considering life insurance, you're planning and preparing for an event that most of us would rather not think about. But life insurance represents a critical step in managing your personal finances and ensuring your family's well-being. - read more
|