Life Insurance Australia :: News
SHARE

Share this news item!

Insurer Failed Property Owner by Sending Carpenter to Assess Flood-Damaged Driveway

Insurer Failed Property Owner by Sending Carpenter to Assess Flood-Damaged Driveway

Insurer Failed Property Owner by Sending Carpenter to Assess Flood-Damaged Driveway?w=400
A property owner faced a frustrating situation when his driveway was blocked for over six weeks due to landslides caused by a severe storm.
To make matters worse, his insurance company initially sent a carpenter instead of an engineer to assess the damage, resulting in a poor claims handling experience.
However, the property owner's persistence paid off as his claim was eventually accepted and he received compensation.

The property owner filed his claim on February 25 last year after his area experienced heavy rainfall and landslides. The storm led to a blockage of debris on his driveway, making it impossible for him to access his home. For more than a month, he had to stay with a family member until he and some friends managed to temporarily fix the driveway, with the insurer's approval.

Inadequate Assessment

Suncorp, the insurer, acknowledged that the storm had indeed affected the area but disputed that it was a one-off event responsible for the damages. Initially, the insurer appointed a carpenter referred to as JLG to assess the property. However, JLG's expertise was questioned by the property owner, as he believed that an engineer was needed for an accurate evaluation.

Later, an engineer appointed by the insurer, referred to as ECE, reported that the erosion under the driveway was caused by a lack of proper drainage. According to ECE's findings, the damage was a result of a structural fault, which was not covered by the property owner's insurance policy.

Contradictory Findings

The property owner contested ECE's findings, claiming that they were inherently inconsistent. He pointed out that the engineer's report initially stated that there was "no drainage alongside the driveway," but later identified drainage in the same report. To counter the insurer's expert, the property owner hired an engineer of his own.

Furthermore, he provided video evidence showing that the gulley on the driveway was working effectively before the storm. He argued that the storm overwhelmed the drainage system, rendering it ineffective. He also highlighted that other roads in the area faced similar issues due to the landslides.

Acknowledging Inappropriate Assessment

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) recognized the inadequacy of JLG's assessment, referring to him as an "unsuitable contractor with irrelevant expertise." AFCA's ombudsman conceded that a carpenter like JLG was not qualified to provide an opinion on the property damage and the risk of driveway failure. The use of an inappropriate expert and the extended waiting period for the report were deemed violations of good industry practice.

AFCA also highlighted the limitations of ECE's conclusions, stating that the engineer did not consider the probable impact of the storm on the drainage system failures. The assessment of the drainage system did not account for the relevant standards present when the road was constructed several decades ago. Additionally, the expert reports failed to consider the significant rainfall during the storm, which could have overwhelmed even a better quality drainage system.

Resolution and Compensation

The ruling required Suncorp to seek quotes from qualified tradespeople to repair the driveway. The insurer was then required to settle the claim based on the higher of the two quotes, along with a 20% contingency for the transfer of risk. Suncorp also had to reimburse the property owner for the temporary repairs carried out, cover the professional costs for expert reports, and compensate him for non-financial losses amounting to $2000.

AFCA acknowledged that Suncorp's handling of the claim was delayed due to a high volume of claims from floods in NSW and Queensland. However, they determined that this only partially justified the delays. The communication breakdowns between the insurer and the property owner significantly impacted the claims process, and Suncorp apologized for these issues.

To read the full ruling by AFCA, click here: (source)

Published:Saturday, 11th Nov 2023
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Landmark NSW Decision: Dog Walking Costs Covered in Car Crash Injury Claims Landmark NSW Decision: Dog Walking Costs Covered in Car Crash Injury Claims
03 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

In a groundbreaking decision by the NSW Personal Injury Commission, an insurer has been directed to cover the costs of dog walking services for a car crash victim. The commission ruled that these services classify as domestic assistance under the state’s Motor Accident Injuries Act. This case could pave the way for broader interpretations of 'attendant care services' for claimants. - read more
Extreme Weather Drives $1.8 Billion in First Half Losses for Australian Insurers Extreme Weather Drives $1.8 Billion in First Half Losses for Australian Insurers
03 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

Extreme weather events in Australia have resulted in significant financial impacts for insurers, tallying $1.83 billion in losses during the first half of the year. This comes as insurance companies gear up for further claims linked to ongoing severe weather in New South Wales. - read more
ClearView Names New Underwriting Head Amidst Strategic Changes ClearView Names New Underwriting Head Amidst Strategic Changes
30 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori

ASX-listed life insurer ClearView has announced the appointment of Peter Tilocca as Head of Underwriting, coinciding with key updates to its underwriting standards and definitions. Tilocca's extensive two-decade career in Australian underwriting includes leadership roles at Zurich, Noble Oak, One Path Life, and RGA Australia. His new role with ClearView commenced on 30 June. - read more
Ombudsman Supports Theft Claimant in Home Business Coverage Dispute Ombudsman Supports Theft Claimant in Home Business Coverage Dispute
30 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori

A recent case has seen a policyholder triumph over her insurer after the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) ruled in her favour following a contentious dispute regarding home business operations. The controversy arose when the woman's theft claim was denied by her insurance provider, IAG, over allegations of fraudulent misrepresentation about the use of her rental property. - read more
AFCA Upholds Insurance Fraud Ruling Over Disputed Possum Accident AFCA Upholds Insurance Fraud Ruling Over Disputed Possum Accident
26 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori

A motorist's claim that he crashed into a tree to avoid a possum has been denied by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), which supported the insurer's fraud decision. The incident involved the driver crashing his Jeep—insured for over $20,000—on a dimly-lit street, purportedly avoiding the rain-soaked motorway en route to the store. - read more


Life Insurance Articles

Understanding the Role of Life Insurance in Financial Security Understanding the Role of Life Insurance in Financial Security
Life insurance can seem complex at first, but understanding the basics can help demystify this important financial product. At its core, life insurance is a contract between you and an insurer, where the insurer promises to pay a designated beneficiary a sum of money upon your passing, in exchange for premium payments. - read more
The Savvy Consumer’s Guide to Purchasing Life Insurance in Australia The Savvy Consumer’s Guide to Purchasing Life Insurance in Australia
As the landscape of finance and personal security evolves in Australia, the importance of being insured has never been more prominent. In a world of changing family dynamics, economic pressures, and higher living costs, life insurance stands as a bastion of support ensuring the well-being of loved ones in the event of unforeseen circumstances. - read more
Top 5 Reasons to Consider Life Insurance While You're Young Top 5 Reasons to Consider Life Insurance While You're Young
When you’re young, life is all about new experiences and making plans for a promising future. While factors like travel, career, and relationships often take centre stage, one aspect often overlooked is life insurance. It might seem like something to consider later in life, but starting a policy while you're young can be a savvy financial move. - read more
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Comparing Life Insurance Policies Common Mistakes to Avoid When Comparing Life Insurance Policies
Choosing the right life insurance policy is one of the most important decisions for Australians, especially for those who are middle-aged or older. Life insurance provides financial security for your loved ones in the event of your passing, ensuring that they are not burdened with financial hardships. - read more
Maximize Your Safety Net: Top Tips for Optimizing Income Protection Benefits Maximize Your Safety Net: Top Tips for Optimizing Income Protection Benefits
Welcome to a pivotal guide dedicated to empowering you with the essentials of income protection insurance in Australia. As we navigate through times of uncertainty, safeguarding your financial wellbeing becomes not just a priority, but a necessity. Income protection insurance stands as one of the key pillars of financial security, ensuring a steady flow of income during periods when you're unable to work due to illness or injury. - read more
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Comparing Life Insurance Policies Common Mistakes to Avoid When Comparing Life Insurance Policies
Choosing the right life insurance policy is one of the most important decisions for Australians, especially for those who are middle-aged or older. Life insurance provides financial security for your loved ones in the event of your passing, ensuring that they are not burdened with financial hardships. - read more
How Pre-Existing Conditions Influence Life Insurance Premiums How Pre-Existing Conditions Influence Life Insurance Premiums
When it comes to life insurance, a pre-existing condition refers to any medical condition or illness that you have been diagnosed with before applying for a life insurance policy. - read more
The Savvy Consumer’s Guide to Purchasing Life Insurance in Australia The Savvy Consumer’s Guide to Purchasing Life Insurance in Australia
As the landscape of finance and personal security evolves in Australia, the importance of being insured has never been more prominent. In a world of changing family dynamics, economic pressures, and higher living costs, life insurance stands as a bastion of support ensuring the well-being of loved ones in the event of unforeseen circumstances. - read more
Maximize Your Safety Net: Top Tips for Optimizing Income Protection Benefits Maximize Your Safety Net: Top Tips for Optimizing Income Protection Benefits
Welcome to a pivotal guide dedicated to empowering you with the essentials of income protection insurance in Australia. As we navigate through times of uncertainty, safeguarding your financial wellbeing becomes not just a priority, but a necessity. Income protection insurance stands as one of the key pillars of financial security, ensuring a steady flow of income during periods when you're unable to work due to illness or injury. - read more
Understanding Life Insurance: How to Determine Coverage Amounts Understanding Life Insurance: How to Determine Coverage Amounts
Life insurance is a cornerstone of financial planning, offering peace of mind to you and security for your loved ones. It's a contract between you and an insurance company: in exchange for regular premiums, the insurer agrees to pay a sum of money to designated beneficiaries upon your passing. This vital tool ensures that your family's financial needs can be met during an incredibly difficult time. - read more


Start Here !
life insurance
Apply now for your free Insurance assessment and price comparisons!

Start Here

Life Cover Amount:
Postcode:

All quotes are provided free and without obligation. We respect your privacy.

Knowledgebase
Insurance Policy:
Broadly, the entire written contract of insurance. More narrowly, the basic written or printed document, as distinguished from the forms and endorsements added thereto.