Leaving the Scene of an Accident Results in Denied Insurance Claim

The Incident

In May of last year, the driver of a Porsche 911 Carrera S Cabriolet crashed into a shed while returning home to pick up his wallet. The incident occurred late at night, and the driver reported that he had "lost concentration" while turning a poorly lit corner. After hitting a gutter, the car collided with the shed.

Investigation and Dispute

Following the crash, the insurer appointed an investigator who interviewed the driver and inspected the circumstances of the incident. The report identified that the driver crashed his car while returning home to pick up his wallet. Additionally, the driver reported feeling disoriented and having issues concentrating due to a lack of sleep from mental health issues and ongoing divorce proceedings.

The police also attended the scene and observed that both the driver and passenger doors of the car were wide open. They charged the driver with negligent driving and a failure to give particulars, which the insurer interpreted as a breach of their policy's conditions, specifically, a failure to "not leave the scene of an accident until lawfully allowed to do so."

The insurer argued that the driver's decision to leave the scene prejudiced their ability to assess the cause and circumstances of the accident, resulting in a denied claim. However, the driver and the insurer disputed this interpretation of events, with the driver stating that he thought he had hit a tree, not a shed. He did not realize that he had hit a building until the next morning when he returned to the scene, and he did contact the police and provide them with his particulars within 24 hours of the accident.

The Ruling

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) reviewed the case and determined that the insurer had not proven that the driver had unlawfully left the scene of the accident and that the available information did not support this conclusion. AFCA stated that there was "no legitimate basis" to reject the driver's statement that he thought he had hit a tree. The man had also made reasonable attempts to contact the shed owner and provided the police with his particulars within 24 hours of the accident.

As a result, AFCA concluded that the insurer should cover the driver's claim under the policy. However, they denied the driver's request for a hire car, stating that the policy only covered hire cars for "not at fault accidents." The insurer was also required to reimburse the driver for professional costs from his lawyer fees, up to a limit of $5000.

Conclusion

When involved in an accident, it is critical to adhere to your insurer's policy's conditions to ensure that your claim is not denied. However, in this case, the insurer did not have a legitimate basis to reject the driver's claim, as the available information did not support that he left the scene unlawfully. It is essential to carefully review your policy's terms and seek legal advice if necessary to ensure that you receive fair treatment in the event of an accident.

Click here for the AFCA's ruling on the case.

Published:Friday, 26th May 2023
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Antique Car Claim Hits the Brakes: Home Insurance Does Not Cover Vehicle Damage 24 Apr 2024: .Paige Estritori In an intriguing turn of events, a dedicated car enthusiast's claim for damages to his vintage vehicle under home insurance has been denied after a careful review by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). The individual's relic, a 1970 Mercedes-Benz 280e sedan, which was being lovingly restored and was far from operational, rolled into an adjacent van following the snap of a winch cable. - read more

Communities Laud Insurance Improvements Post-Flood Events 23 Apr 2024: .Paige Estritori Residents and officials from regions affected by flooding have observed a discernable shift in insurers' handling of claims following natural catastrophes, with recent proceedings reflecting a more positive trajectory. This outlook emerged during a federal inquiry session that gave a voice to flood-impacted communities in Heathcote, Victoria. - read more

Traveler's Appeal on Wildfire Claim Denied by Adjudicator 22 Apr 2024: .Paige Estritori An individual's anticipation of a serene vacation in Hawaii was met with a grievous twist when wildfires ravaged Maui, leading to an urgent evacuation and unplanned expenses. A customer of Mitsui Sumitomo ventured to the Pacific paradise only to have plans upended by nature's wrath. The ensuing insurance claim denial sparked a dispute which has now been resolved by the authoritative voice of the industry’s dispute resolver, leaving a glaring reminder of the importance of scrutinizing insurance options. - read more

Life Insurance Participation Drops By Nearly One-Fifth in Five Years 19 Apr 2024: .Paige Estritori Last year, research from a major insurance provider signaled a significant shift in the life insurance landscape within Australia, showing a marked decrease in the percentage of insured non-dependent adults of working age. Only 77% now carry some form of life insurance, a stark contrast to the 94% coverage rate recorded in 2017. Industries evolve, yet the dip in these figures marks a noteworthy trend within the life insurance sector. - read more

London's CFC Gears Up for Australian Expansion With Local Acquisition 18 Apr 2024: .Paige Estritori In a strategic move to fortify its Australian footprint, the prominent London-based cyber insurance firm CFC has announced the procurement of Melbourne's Solution Underwriting. Already an experienced player in the Australian insurance sector, CFC’s recent acquisition marks a significant augmentation of its local operations. - read more