When Insurance Doesn't Cover Property Damage: One Homeowner's Experience
The Shocking Gaps in Coverage: Lessons from a Denied Fire Damage Claim
The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.
A homeowner recently learned the hard way that just because you have insurance doesn't mean you're fully covered when disaster strikes.
In this case, a homeowner's investment property was damaged in a fire - started by the homeowner's son - but the insurance company refused the claim.
The Fire and the Claim
On February 17, 2021, a property owned by a homeowner was set on fire. The homeowner submitted a claim to their insurer, Suncorp. Unfortunately, Suncorp denied the claim, citing a clause in the policy's Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) that specifically excluded coverage for malicious acts and vandalism committed by a resident of the insured address with the policyholder's consent.
In this case, the homeowner's son - who was living in the property at the time - had caused the fire and subsequently pleaded guilty.
The Policy Exclusions
The exclusion the insurer cited is a common one in insurance policies. Policies contain various exclusions that limit coverage, and it's important for policyholders to review these carefully and understand what is and isn't covered.
In this case, the exclusion applied to the son's deliberate act that demonstrated "a reckless disregard for the consequences." The fact that the homeowner didn't consent to the fire was irrelevant because the son was living at the property with the homeowner's consent.
The Insurance Claim Dispute
The homeowner argued that the exclusion shouldn't apply because they didn't consent to their son lighting the fire. However, Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) disagreed, stating that the exclusion applied to anyone living at the property with the insured's consent. The panel said that it was satisfied that the son had caused the fire and that the exclusion applied.
Notably, while the court refused to record the son's guilty plea due to concerns about his mental health, AFCA said that there was not enough information about his state of mind to overrule the insurer's decision. AFCA added that the complainant could ask Suncorp to reassess its liability once a psychiatric report was provided and the court outcome had been determined.
The Settlement Offer
Following the claim's denial, Suncorp offered the homeowner an ex-gratia payment of $261,318, which the homeowner deemed insufficient for repair costs. The homeowner sought an additional $166,159 or $261,328, based on quotes provided.
However, AFCA noted that Suncorp's offer had been based on an itemised repair quote from an assessment by the insurer's builder, which the panel deemed fair.
Conclusion
Insurance policies can be complex and challenging to navigate, especially when dealing with policy exclusions. In this case, the homeowner's insurance policy didn't cover damages caused by their son, even though the homeowner didn't consent to the fire. Understanding the specifics of your policy - including the exclusions - is critical in knowing precisely what you are and aren't covered for.
Please Note: We do not endorse any specific products or companies. Some content is sourced from third parties, including press releases, and may not be independently verified for accuracy or completeness.
In recent years, Australia's strata insurance market has experienced notable shifts, primarily driven by escalating climate risks and increasing claims costs. As we move through 2026, these factors continue to influence premium rates and underwriting practices, presenting challenges for owners corporations and strata managers. - read more
As the Australian insurance sector approaches 2026, Deloitte has released a comprehensive report detailing eight pivotal predictions that are set to reshape the industry. These insights provide a roadmap for insurers to adapt and thrive amidst evolving challenges and opportunities. - read more
The Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) has released its latest statistics, indicating a notable increase in general insurance premiums placed through intermediaries. This trend reflects the dynamic nature of Australia's insurance landscape and offers insights into the sector's current trajectory. - read more
As the Australian insurance landscape continues to evolve, Deloitte has released its 2026 Insurance Predictions, highlighting pivotal trends that are set to reshape the industry. These insights are particularly relevant for self-employed professionals seeking to understand how these changes may impact their coverage options and risk management strategies. - read more
In a strategic move to bolster national fuel security, the Australian government has announced amendments to the Export Finance and Insurance Corporation Act. These changes grant Export Finance Australia (EFA) enhanced authority to underwrite additional cargoes of critical imports, including fuel and fertiliser, addressing challenges posed by escalating risk premiums that have been affecting independent importers. - read more
Choosing the right life insurance policy is one of the most important decisions for Australians, especially for those who are middle-aged or older. Life insurance provides financial security for your loved ones in the event of your passing, ensuring that they are not burdened with financial hardships. - read more
For many millennials, navigating the complexities of personal finance and future planning can feel like a bewildering journey. Among these financial responsibilities, life insurance emerges as a paramount consideration. More than just a safety net, life insurance can be the cornerstone of a sound financial strategy, providing peace of mind for both the policyholder and their loved ones. - read more
Life insurance is a crucial part of any comprehensive financial plan, providing peace of mind that your loved ones will be financially secure in the event of your passing. - read more
Life insurance, a contract between an insurer and a policyholder, is designed to provide financial protection to loved ones in the event of the policyholder's death. For parents, this protection takes on a new level of significance. The birth of a child heralds a profound shift in priorities, with a focus on safeguarding the future of one's family. Hence, understanding life insurance options becomes a crucial aspect of responsible parenting. - read more
The digital age has fundamentally transformed how we approach almost every aspect of our lives, including the way we shop for life insurance in Australia. Gone are the days when one had to schedule meetings with insurance agents or flip through pamphlets to understand life insurance policies. Today, obtaining life insurance quotes online has become the norm, offering a hassle-free and incredibly accessible platform for individuals to safeguard their financial future. - read more
Start Here !
Apply now for your free Insurance assessment and price comparisons!
Knowledgebase
Insurance broker: An agent acting on behalf of the insured (not the insurance company) who negotiates the terms and cover provided by the insurer in the insurance policy.
